Hello everyone, this is Marcela and I am currently taking violence
in art and culture class at LaGuardia Community College. In class we been
reading Caesar’s Column (a story of the twentieth century) by Donnelly. Reading
this book something came up to mind. For example, the way that woman are
portrayed in the story so far. If we take the conversion between Gabriel and
Max on the beginning of chapter five, they start talking about the two young
ladies they saw (previously in the book ) in a carriage that is property of the
prince Cabano. Gabriel is intrigue with lady that is younger from the two. He asks
Max if he know anything about her and Max replies that they might be the Prince’s
mistress, upon hearing this Gabriel is shocked. He can’t believe such a fine
lady can reduce herself and become a mistress to the prince. He starts talking
about freedom and how wrong it is for a woman to sell her body. We often see
this throughout history that woman are frown upon because many choose to sell
their body for a living these is often seen as something sinful. Continuing with
the topic of woman on pg. 38, we see how they see woman as a parasite. ”women are
not in their best fortunes strong, but want will perjure the ne'er-touched
vestal.” “But he need not have confined this observation to women. The strongest
resolves of men melt in the fire of want like figures of wax…where virtue inevitably
breaks. Morality in man or woman is a magnificent flower which blossoms only in
the rich soil of prosperity…” “Dignity, decency, honor, fade away when man or
woman is reduce to shabby, shameful, degrading, cruel wretchedness. Before the
clamors of the stomach the soul is silent”. The concept that the passage is
saying is woman are a man distraction, when woman are placed in front of man
they forget who they are and forget what their role in society, which is
helping the community prosper. Women are the want of men but not necessary the
need of men. They ignite the fire in men and due to the fire the men (figures)
turn to wax. With that being said Morality should only be consider a man trait
rather than a women. A women isn't anything in society but a house wife,
bringing the religion moral that women shouldn't be educated but rather be
teach their role in society. Which is staying pure until marriage and then
baring children and being a housewife. “Purity is natural to woman…god never
placed such a majestic and noble countenance over a corrupt soul. The face is
transparent; the spirit looks out of the great eyes; and it is a spirit of
dignity, nobleness, grace and goodness”. The ideal that if a woman is pure she
already lost her dignity, nobleness, grace and goodness and now is replace with
a corrupt soul. Religion plays a role her because god is who created a woman
out of a man’s rib, he made her pure and noble and with the idea that she will
serve her man. Also the idea that a woman that if a women isn't pure she is
degrading and shameful comes from the religious view. In conclusion I claim that these passages theme overall Is how woman are view and why they view like
this.
Your blog entry explores many interesting ideas about the perception of woman in this novel. One idea in particular, the idea that woman are either "pure" or "sinful" is one that I feel is worth exploring in more detail. I also liked how you brought up religion as a key factor in these perceptions. It would be helpful to the reader however if you provided more context about the passages that you are citing. The fact that it is Max declaring that everyone is corruptible, and that Gabriel believes otherwise (at least when it comes to Estella) is one of the most important aspects of this entire chapter. In addition to helping the reader better understand what is going in the passage, these details could be used to strengthen your argument.
ReplyDeleteIn the future you might try to read your blog entry aloud after finishing it. This is a useful technique to help you pick out mistakes you've made in regards to tense. In addition breaking your blog entry into paragraphs, especially when you have written a lot, can improve readability.
Two questions that I have now are,
Do all of the female characters in the novel fall within the pure and sinful categories? Are there any exceptions?
How does this dichotomy reflect Gabriel's and perhaps the author's, religious views?